What is Triplet-Triplet Annihilation?

Triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA) is an energy transfer process where two molecules in their triplet excited state interact to produce two singlet states:

• One molecule transitions to its singlet excited state
• One molecule transitions to its ground singlet state

This energy transfer occurs via the Dexter mechanism, where electron exchange requires the wavefunctions of the two molecules to overlap. Consequently, the two molecules must be in close proximity, typically within 10 Å (1 nm).

The TTA process must obey spin conservation rules, which means the interaction produces a combination of singlet, triplet, and quintet states. Among these, the singlet state is crucial for applications such as photon upconversion, where it can subsequently emit fluorescence.

Energy Transfer Mechanism

---

For triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA) to occur, energy transfer happens as two molecules in their triplet excited states interact. This process can be mediated by Dexter energy transfer, requiring orbital overlap. The interaction allows the system to transition to a combination of singlet, triplet, or quintet states. If the process results in a singlet exciton and a ground-state molecule, there is a change in multiplicity. The spin states of the electrons in the interacting molecules adjust to conserve the total spin quantum number, enabling the transition. For the final singlet state, the electrons must pair with opposite spins to satisfy spin conservation and form a singlet exciton.

In the left-hand diagram below, the dark blue arrows represent the initial state of the electrons and the light blue dashed arrows represent their movement between donor and acceptor. The right-hand diagram represents the final state of the system.

The TTA mechanism depends on the mobility of the acceptor molecule. In systems with high molecular mobility, such as solutions or soft hosts, the molecular diffusion mechanism dominates. In these cases, triplet-excited emitters transport through the system and collide to form encounter complexes capable of TTA.

In systems where donor and acceptor molecules are immobilized, the triplet energy migration mechanism takes precedence. For TTA to occur, neighboring acceptor molecules must both receive triplet energy via energy transfer before interacting.

Spin-Statistics

Statistically, TTA between two triplet state molecules can result in the formation of encounter complexes with three types of spin states: singlet, triplet, and quintet. These states arise due to the combination of the spin angular momenta of the two triplets, leading to multiplicities of 1, 3, and 5, respectively. The probabilities of forming each state are proportional to these multiplicities, resulting in the following distribution:

• Singlet: 1/9 (11.1%)
• Triplet: 3/9 (33.3%)
• Quintet: 5/9 (55.6%)

As a result, only 1/9 of TTA events produce a singlet excited state, which can emit a high-energy photon. This statistical limitation is one of the primary factors constraining the quantum efficiency of TTA-based photon upconversion.

The energetic order of singlet, triplet, and quintet states was initially believed to be dictated by ferromagnetic coupling (FC), where the resulting encounter complexes followed Hund's rule, with the quintet state being the lowest in energy and the singlet state the highest. However, it is now thought that antiferromagnetic coupling dominates, reversing the energetic order of these multiplicity states. Therefore, higher energy triplet and quintet encounter complexes can relax back to the T₁ state non-radiatively to takes part in TTA reaction again to give the excited singlet state.

To improve efficiency, researchers focus on selecting donor and acceptor molecules with optimized energy levels and employing material strategies that minimize quenching and enhance the rate of productive TTA events.

Triplet-Triplet Annihilation Upconversion

---

One important application of triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA) is TTA photon upconversion (TTA-UC). This method allows two low energy photons to be “converted” into a single high energy photon, demonstrating a phenomenon known as an anti-Stokes shift. Systems that exploit TTA-UC contain acceptor and donor molecules:

• Donor molecules: triplet sensitizers, able to harvest triplet state energy and transfer it to the acceptor molecules.
• Acceptor molecules: Excited triplet-state acceptor molecules can then undergo TTA, resulting in anti-Stokes delayed fluorescence, as the singlet excited state of the acceptor lies at a higher energy than its triplet excited state.

The process of TTA-UC proceeds as follows:

• The singlet excited state of the donor molecules becomes populated by an electron through photon absorption.
• This excited electron undergoes intersystem crossing (ISC), non-radiatively transitioning to the triplet excited state.
• Dexter triplet-triplet energy transfer occurs, transferring energy from the triplet excited state of the donor to the acceptor, forming triplet excited state acceptor molecules.
• If two triplet excited state acceptors are within 1 nm, their orbital overlap allows triplet-triplet annihilation to occur.
• One acceptor molecule transforms into its singlet excited state and one transforms into its singlet ground state.

Anti-Stokes Shift

An anti-Stokes shift occurs when the emitted light has a shorter wavelength (higher energy) than the absorbed light. Triplet-triplet annihilation promotes this shift and is calculated as the difference between the excitation wavelength of the donor molecule (sensitizer) and the wavelength maximum of the upconverted emission of the acceptor molecule (annihilator).

TTA-UC Applications

The absorption of photons with low energy and the subsequent upconversion to access higher energy states is highly attractive to a range of applications. It has also gained interest for various other photonic applications including organic light-emitting diodes (OLED), biomedicine, sensing and photovoltaics.

Organic Light-Emitting Diodes (OLEDs)

The formation of high-energy excited states of light emitting molecules can be suppressed by using triplet-triplet annihilation emitters. This reduces the risk of chemical decomposition and increases overall device stability. Triplet-triplet annihilation is often described as an energy loss mechanism in phosphorescent and thermally activated delayed fluorescent OLED devices. Due to the high energy of singlet excited state this can lead to decomposition and instability.

TTA improves OLED device performance by enabling access to blue light emission. The upconversion mechanism allows for high-energy emission, facilitating the production of blue TTA OLEDs with high external quantum efficiency (EQE), reduced efficiency roll-off, and enhanced stability.

Biomedical

Triplet-triplet annihilation upconversion from near infrared (NIR) to visible light is particularly useful in biomedical imaging applications. Biological tissue only very weakly absorbs NIR light so it can penetrate deeper into the body. The lower energy of NIR means it is also less likely to damage healthy cells and biomolecules. If this can then be converted to visible light following TTA-UC then biological probing or imaging is possible. Visible light generated via TTA-UC can activate targeted photosensitizers for therapeutic effects. Excited photosensitizers generate reactive oxygen species which can kill cancer cells or pathogens.

Photovoltaics

Molecular photon upconversion via triplet–triplet annihilation (TTA-UC) is a strategy to increase solar cell efficiencies and surpass the Shockley–Quiesser (SQ) limit. This process converts low energy near-infrared (NIR) light, which constitutes half of the solar radiation intensity, into ultraviolet and visible light. These higher-energy photons can then activate light-responsive materials in devices such as solar cells.

Molecular Design of TTA Molecules

---

Acceptor / Annihilator Molecules

Acceptor molecules, also known as annihilators, are the components that can undergo triplet-triplet annihilation. They accept triplet energy from sensitizer/donor molecules. The requirements of triplet acceptors are:

• The annihilation of the triplet state is able to product the singlet excited state
• The triplet excited state energy level should be more than half of that of the singlet excited state: 2 E_T1 > E_S1
• High fluorescence quantum yield
• Modifiable triplet excited state T₁ energy level
• Good photochemical stability

Triplet-Triplet Annihilation (TTA) materials often rely on anthracene as a core structural motif, and derivatives of anthracene have been extensively explored to enhance TTA performance. Derivatives such as cyano-anthracene, nitrogen heterocycle-anthracene, imidazole, and phosphine oxide-anthracene have been investigated.

Rubrene is a popular annihilator molecule but is prone to endoperoxidation upon interaction with singlet oxygen. This is made likely as singlet oxygen is generated by the interaction of triplet state with molecular oxygen.

Donor / Sensitizer Molecules

Donor molecules within triplet-triplet annihilation systems are often referred to as sensitizers. They absorb incident photons, undergo intersystem crossing to populate their triplet state, and transfer the triplet energy to acceptor (annihilator) molecules. The key properties of sensitizer molecules are:

• Strong light absorption - efficient photon absorption in the desired wavelength range
• Efficient intersystem cross - important in populating the triplet state
• Long triplet state lifetimes - increase the probability of successful Dexter energy transfer
• High triplet energy levels - higher than triplet of acceptor molecules
• Compatible within the system - enhance device stability
• High photostability

A broad range of materials have been explored as sensitizers including:

Material	Key Features
Metal-organic complexes	Strong absorption, high ISC rates, tunable energy levels.
Quantum dots	Tunable absorption via size control, stable triplet states.
BODIPY radicals	High ISC efficiency, excellent photostability.
Nanoparticles/nanoclusters	Long triplet lifetimes, broad absorption spectra.
Thiosquaraines	Tunable triplet energy levels, high efficiency in TTA processes.
Osmium complexes	Direct S₀-to-T₁ absorption, heavy-atom ISC enhancement.
TADF molecules	Efficient triplet harvesting, high chemical compatibility.
Perovskite nanocrystals	Customizable photophysical properties, tunable bandgaps.

Challenges of Triplet-Triplet Annihilation

---

Triplet-triplet annihilation faces several challenges that limit its efficiency, scalability, and applicability. These challenges arise from both molecular design limitations and environmental factors that affect the energy transfer and annihilation processes. The table below shows a summary of the challenges that TTA faces:

Challenge	Explanation	Impact	Possible Solutions
Oxygen Quenching	Oxygen molecules readily quench triplet states by reacting to form singlet oxygen species	This depletes the number of available triplet states for TTA. Singlet oxygen can degrade the molecular components, reducing device stability.	Need oxygen-free or inert environments (e.g., nitrogen or argon atmospheres). Encapsulate TTA systems in oxygen-barrier materials Use scavengers to remove residual oxygen.
Limited Energy Transfer Efficiency	Efficient Dexter energy transfer for TTA requires significant orbital overlap between donor and acceptor molecules - the spatial arrangement of molecules often limits this overlap.	Poor triplet energy transfer reduces the overall rate of productive TTA events.	Design donor-acceptor pairs with complementary energy levels and good electronic coupling. Use materials with tailored packing or alignment, such as liquid crystals or structured polymers.
Energy Losses	During triplet-triplet annihilation, energy loss can occur if the energy of the singlet excited state​ of the acceptor is not precisely matched to twice the energy of its triplet state	Energy mismatch leads to suboptimal upconversion efficiency.	Fine-tune the molecular structure of the acceptor
Concentration Quenching	High concentrations of acceptor molecules are often needed to facilitate efficient TTA. However, this can lead to aggregation-induced quenching or energy losses through self-absorption.	Aggregates reduce the efficiency of triplet energy transfer and photon emission	Use steric hindrance or bulky substituents to prevent molecular aggregation. Develop host-guest systems where the acceptor is dispersed within a matrix to minimize quenching interactions.
Narrow Operating Conditions	TTA is highly sensitive to the physical and chemical environment, such as temperature, viscosity, and solvent polarity.	In rigid systems, triplet diffusion is hindered, reducing efficiency. In solutions, dynamic quenching processes can reduce the lifetime of triplet states.	Design flexible materials that allow molecular diffusion in solid-state systems, such as soft polymer matrices or gels. Carefully optimize the solvent and host materials for a given TTA system.
Wavelength Range Limitations	Most TTA-UC systems are limited to converting visible photons into other visible photons, with fewer systems capable of NIR-to-visible or UV-to-visible upconversion.	This limits the applicability of TTA in areas like bioimaging and photovoltaics, where NIR-to-visible upconversion is desirable.	Explore donor and acceptor molecules with broader absorption and emission spectra. Develop hybrid systems combining TTA with plasmonic or nanostructured materials to expand the wavelength range.
Stability and Longevity	Molecular degradation due to repeated excitation cycles, exposure to light, or interaction with oxygen can reduce the lifespan of TTA systems.	Device lifetime and operational stability are significantly limited, especially in commercial applications like OLEDs and bioimaging.	Use photostable materials with high chemical robustness. Encapsulate TTA systems in protective barriers to minimize degradation.
Scalability Challenges	Translating TTA from lab-scale systems to scalable, cost-effective commercial applications is challenging due to complex material synthesis and stringent environmental requirements.	High costs and technical barriers limit widespread adoption of TTA-based technologies.	Develop simpler synthetic pathways for TTA materials. Integrate TTA systems with low-cost production techniques, such as solution processing

OLED Materials

Buy now

Learn More

---